New Rochelle First
A Civic Movement
Evidence, not rumor

City Assessment

What do the records say about how New Rochelle is doing? These pages report the City's finances, leadership process, downtown development, traffic, fire and safety, tax abatements, local businesses and purchasing. Each statement is labeled by how well it is supported, and links to its sources with dates.

Look for the label on every statement. Verified means a primary record or two independent sources. Reported means one outlet or the City about itself. Allegation, Opinion, Unresolved and Not found are shown the same way. Nothing here is a finding by a court or agency.

Last reviewed September 26, 2026

2.46%
Verified
City property tax rate increase for 2026

About $103 more a year for the average home, according to the City.

$23.1M
Verified
General Fund unassigned balance, end of 2025

It was $10.5 million a year earlier, the lowest in ten years.

Aa2
Reported
City credit rating, per the City

Moody's affirmed it in November 2025. The City says it has held Aa2 since 2017.

$208.5M
Verified
Net IDA tax exemptions, fiscal 2017 to 2024

$231.3 million exempted, less $22.8 million in PILOT payments made.

2,120
Verified
Employer businesses in the city's ZIP codes, 2023

There were 2,165 in 2018. Full-service restaurants fell from 86 to 71.

1,228
Verified
Index crimes reported to police, 2024

That is 22% below 2012 and 8.6% above 2019. Violent index crimes were 6.8% below 2019.

171 of 895
Verified
City facility accessibility features the State Comptroller found need improvement (Feb 2025)

That is 19% of the ADA items checked at City Hall, the Senior Center, the Police/Court building and Fire HQ. The City agreed with the findings and said it plans corrective action.

196
Verified
New downtown public parking spaces, March 2026

The City says that is about 7% more downtown parking.

0
Not found
Published before-and-after downtown traffic counts found

The City's own 2021 findings predicted worse service at most of 29 studied intersections.

Oct. 27
Verified
Scheduled date of the 2026 State of the City address

Not yet delivered as of September 26, 2026. The Charter sets no date.

State Audit · February 2025

Accessibility at City Facilities

Verified

The NYS Comptroller reviewed 895 ADA accessibility features at four City buildings (audit period Jan 2023 – Jun 2024) and found 171 (19%) where the City could do more — from missing parking signs to ramps that are too steep and doorways narrower than 32 inches.

97
City Hall

Van-parking signs, ramp slope, narrow doors, restrooms

38
Senior Center

Unmarked accessible parking, no Braille signs, twist handles

20
Police / Court

Elevator doors don't reopen, fixtures mounted too high

16
Fire HQ

Ramp missing a handrail, loose entrance mat

Worst categories: signs (25 of 32, 78%), curb ramps (40%), ramps (33%), elevators (21%), parking (20%). No issues were found with accessible routes, rooms or seating.

City's response: officials agreed with the findings and said they plan to start corrective action.

We have not found a public record of which fixes have been completed since the audit.

Read the full Comptroller report (PDF)
City Policy Document · Revised March 29, 2023

How Developer Tax Breaks Work — the NRIDA Uniform Tax Exemption Policy

Verified

The New Rochelle Industrial Development Agency (NRIDA) is the city body that grants tax incentives to developers. State law requires it to publish a Uniform Tax Exemption Policy (UTEP) — the rulebook for who gets tax breaks, how much, and when they can be taken back. The current policy was adopted in 2016 and revised six times, most recently on March 29, 2023.

Three incentive tools

Exemptions from sales & use tax and mortgage recording tax, plus real estate tax abatements delivered through PILOT (payment-in-lieu-of-taxes) agreements.

10-year downtown PILOTs

Residential rental and commercial projects in the Downtown Overlay District typically receive 10-year PILOT agreements with a graduated abatement schedule (Schedule A) covering County, City and School taxes.

Social Equity Program

Every project must source 15% of total costs from local hire, union labor, or Women/Minority-Owned Business Enterprises — or pay a compliance penalty of $30 per net square foot, reduced by the percentage actually met.

Deviations & clawbacks

The NRIDA can grant bigger or longer breaks case-by-case after a cost-benefit analysis, and its clawback guidelines allow benefits to be suspended or recaptured if a project fails to deliver.

This summary paraphrases the policy document; the full text controls. Read the original for exact terms, schedules and definitions.

Read the full policy (PDF)
Agency Budget · 2026 Adopted Budget

The NRIDA's Own Budget — 2026 Adopted Budget

Verified

The NRIDA funds itself mainly through fees charged to the projects it assists — not directly from city taxes. Its 2026 budget shows how dependent that model is on new development deals closing.

2026 revenue: $870,400

Of that, $789,000 is one-time "transaction fees" from new development deals — nearly triple the 2025 projection of $217,232. The budget depends on a big jump in deals closing.

2026 spending: $397,600

The largest line is a $200,000 annual "Contract Services – City" payment to the City of New Rochelle, plus $150,000 for consultants and $25,000 for legal.

Reserves are shrinking

The agency's net position fell from $465,399 at the start of 2024 to a projected $244,058 at the start of 2026 — it spent more than it took in during 2024 and 2025.

Optimistic projections

The 2027–2029 outlook assumes transaction fees keep growing ($1.2M in 2027, $1.7M in 2028), rebuilding reserves to over $3.1M by 2029 — entirely dependent on the development pipeline.

Note: the document's column headers say "Proposed" while the file is titled "Adopted." Figures are quoted exactly as published in the budget document.

Read the full budget (PDF)
Certified State Filings · FY 2025 (certified March 31, 2026)

NRIDA Debt & Spending — 2025 Certified State Filings

Verified

Every year the NRIDA must file certified reports with the state's Public Authorities Reporting Information System (PARIS). The 2025 filings show what the agency owes and who it pays.

$28.1M in conduit debt

Outstanding conduit debt fell from $28,639,311 to $28,139,510 during 2025 — $499,801 retired, no new debt issued. Conduit debt is repaid by the assisted projects, not by the agency or taxpayers.

Four vendors, ~$337,600

All 2025 procurement spending went to four vendors: City of New Rochelle $200,000, National Development Council $112,363, Harris Beach Murtha $15,651 (legal), EFPR Group $9,570 (audit).

$200,000 to the City — non-competitive

The largest contract is the staffing and office services payment to the City of New Rochelle itself, awarded without competitive bidding — the same $200,000 line in the 2026 budget.

Legal firm retained since 2015

Harris Beach Murtha's legal services contract dates to December 2015 with no listed end date. The agency reports its procurement guidelines are reviewed annually, allow no exceptions, and that it issues no credit cards.

Schedule of Debt (PDF)Procurement Report (PDF)
In Progress

Nine detailed pages — Leadership, Finances, Development, Fire & Safety, Tax Abatements, Local Economy, Procurement, Open Questions and Methods — are being published here in stages, each with full sourcing and charts. The corrections log below is live now.

Corrections Log

When this site changes a statement about City government, finances or the economy, the change is listed here with the record it rests on. This list starts on September 27, 2026, when earlier pages were reviewed against the City's documents and public data.

Public Accountability, full dossier, count 01 (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"3.46% property tax rate increase in FY2026, adding ~$103/year to the average homeowner's bill."”
Verified

What the record shows: The City's 2026 tax rate rose 2.46%, from $263.230 to $269.695 per $1,000 of assessed value. The City estimates about $103 more a year for the average home. The Council adopted the budget on December 9, 2025.

Now: The Budget and Finances page gives the 2.46% figure, the history since 2016 and each taxing body's share of the bill.

Public Accountability, full dossier, count 01 (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"School taxes also rose 1.86%." "The school district cut roughly 80 staff positions for the 2026-27 school year."”
Verified

What the record shows: Patch reported that the school district put a $370.4 million 2026-27 budget to voters on May 19, 2026, with a 1.85% levy increase and about 80 fewer full-time-equivalent positions. We did not confirm the vote result or the adopted levy.

Now: The Budget and Finances page reports the district's 1.85% proposal and says the vote result was not confirmed.

Public Accountability, full dossier, count 02 (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"Drained the City's Rainy Day Fund ... For the first time in over a decade, the FY2026 budget did not draw on the unassigned fund balance, itself an admission of how depleted those reserves had become."”
Verified

What the record shows: The General Fund's unassigned balance was $24.5 million at the end of 2023, $10.5 million at the end of 2024 (the lowest of ten years) and $23.1 million at the end of 2025. The audited 2025 report ties the rise to ARPA revenue recognition. The City presents the 2026 budget's no-draw policy as a strength. Whether it shows weakness or strength is a judgment, not a finding.

Now: The Budget and Finances page shows the yearly balances, what drove them, and both readings.

Home page "Promised vs. Delivered," the timeline, the carousel and dossier counts 09 and 10 (all removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"Credit rating under pressure." "Credit Score Tanking." "Credit rating dropping." "Moody's watch reports." "Downgraded Bonds?" "Bankruptcy Risk?"”
Reported

What the record shows: On November 26, 2025 the City announced that Moody's affirmed its Aa2 rating and assigned a MIG 1 rating to about $41 million in short-term notes. The City says it has held Aa2 since 2017. We found no downgrade, no rating watch and no source for bankruptcy risk.

Now: The Budget and Finances page reports the rating as the City's statement and lists what we searched.

Home page "Promised vs. Delivered," the timeline and dossier count 09 (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"The city is now running a structural deficit." "The city budget is in deficit." "Budget deficits."”
Verified

What the record shows: The audited 2024 report shows the General Fund balance fell $10.3 million, mainly because the City budgeted a $5.0 million loss and settled a police contract with retroactive pay. The audited 2025 report shows it rose $10.1 million, driven by ARPA revenue recognition. The City adopted a $256.0 million 2026 budget that it calls structurally balanced and within the tax cap. A rise from one-time money does not show that ongoing revenue covers ongoing costs.

Now: The Budget and Finances page reports the 2024 drop, the 2025 rise and the caveat about one-time money. It does not use the word deficit for the General Fund.

Home page "Promised vs. Delivered," the timeline and dossier count 09 (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"City employees are losing overtime." "Essential services are being cut." "No Money Left for Essentials."”
Not found

What the record shows: We found no published record of cuts to City employee overtime or to City services. The budget documents we read do not mention overtime cuts. The school district, which is a separate body, did plan position cuts for 2025-26 and 2026-27.

Where we looked: The City's proposed and adopted 2026 budget releases and the City Manager, Police, Fire, Public Works and capital budget presentations, plus the audited 2024 and 2025 reports.

Now: Nothing replaces it. A records request for overtime spending by department would settle it.

Issues, housing card (removed sentence) · changed September 27, 2026
“"... the city's credit score tanks and its debt-to-credit ratio is maxed out."”
Verified

What the record shows: The audited 2025 report shows net debt of $198.8 million against a constitutional debt limit of $871.8 million. That is 22.81% of the limit, leaving $672.9 million of room. The share was 24.96% a year earlier. The City also carries large retiree health and pension obligations, which are described on the Finances page.

Now: Nothing replaces the sentence. The Budget and Finances page reports the debt-limit figures beside the other long-term obligations.

Issues housing card; home page "Promised vs. Delivered"; the timeline (all removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"ARPA grants meant for affordable housing have been abused and misused by state, county, and local municipalities." "ARPA funds burned through with no accountability."”
Verified

What the record shows: New Rochelle's plan allocates its $37 million ARPA award across five categories: $18.0 million to replace lost revenue, $8.5 million for negative economic impacts, $6.5 million for public health, $2.5 million for water and sewer, and $1.5 million for premium pay. None is a housing category. The audited 2025 report says ARPA money went to 26 capital projects. One sentence in that report names three private buildings and needs an answer from the City. We found no finding that ARPA money was misused.

Now: The Budget and Finances page shows the allocations, the audited description of spending and the unanswered question. A records request asks for the project list.

Public Accountability, full dossier, count 03 (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"$44.7 Million in Tax Breaks to Big Developers ... $11.7M to High Garden Towers and $33M+ to The Stella."”
Verified

What the record shows: The State's IDA data report $231.3 million in exemptions and $22.8 million in PILOT payments made across fiscal 2017 to 2024, or $208.5 million net, on 57 projects approved between 1999 and 2024. The $33 million figure for The Stella is a 30-year projection from 2018 press and a resident-run tracker, and the sources disagree. The state data show $6.81 million in reported exemptions for that building from fiscal 2019 to 2024. The $11.7 million figure for Highgarden is a tracker's 30-year projection. The state data show $3.95 million in reported exemptions from fiscal 2020 to 2024.

Now: The Tax Abatements page reports the IDA's totals by year, tax type and project, and labels the 30-year figures as projections.

Public Accountability, full dossier, counts 03 and 04 (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"The Stella received ... $10M in public grants and $125M in tax-exempt bond financing." "Built with $43M+ in public subsidies."”
Reported

What the record shows: We found no source for "$10 million in public grants" or "$43 million or more in subsidies." Westfair reported that the $190 million project included a $125 million construction loan funded by tax-exempt and taxable bonds issued by New York State's housing agency. Those bonds are not City debt.

Now: The Tax Abatements page reports what the IDA approved and what the financing was, and says the loan documents were not read.

Public Accountability, full dossier, count 04 (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"The Stella was constructed by a contractor whose president was convicted of Enterprise Corruption ... Bribes were paid in a New Rochelle parking lot."”
Verified

What the record shows: The Manhattan District Attorney's releases describe JM3 Construction as a non-union drywall and carpentry subcontractor, not the builder. Its principal pleaded guilty to enterprise corruption on January 9, 2024 and was sentenced to two to six years. The May 2023 release lists 14 Le Count Place among seven projects where false minority- and women-owned business reporting occurred. It does not allege wrongdoing by the developer or the City. The bribe in the release concerned a project in Newark, New Jersey. We found no source for the parking-lot statement.

Now: The Tax Abatements page states what the court records say, that JM3 was a subcontractor, and what the releases do not allege.

Public Accountability, full dossier, count 07 (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"$90k in Nonprofit Grants ... awarded $98,080 to 12 nonprofits in April 2026."”
Verified

What the record shows: The City's THRIVE page lists 12 nonprofits and a total of $99,080, with awards from $1,280 to $20,000. The City's ceremony was on April 20, 2026.

Now: The Budget and Finances page reports $99,080 and 12 nonprofits.

Public Accountability, full dossier, count 08 (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"Executive Order No. 3 limits New Rochelle city employees and police officers from cooperating with federal immigration enforcement absent a legal mandate."”
Not found

What the record shows: We found no Executive Order No. 3 with that content. What is documented is a 2017 City statement that its police department will not engage in immigration enforcement. New RoAR News reported in February 2025 that the Mayor said this is still true, that City policy is to assist federal agents only in pursuit of criminals and only with a judicial warrant, and that officers are trained not to ask about immigration status unless it is needed to investigate a crime.

Where we looked: A web search for the order's number and text, the Mayor's page and the City press releases we read, and news coverage through September 26, 2026.

Now: Nothing replaces it. A records request to the City Clerk for any written policy on cooperation with federal immigration enforcement would settle it.

Carousel slides "Downtown Towers in Trouble" and "Downtown Project Failure" (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"'Great future for New Rochelle' — then why isn't the Mayor running again?" "Why the cash grab if many officials are not seeking re-election?"”
Not found

What the record shows: The Mayor took office in 2024, under a Charter that sets four-year terms, so her term runs through 2027. We found no announcement by the Mayor or by other officials about whether they will run in 2027.

Where we looked: The City's Mayor and Council pages and news coverage through September 26, 2026.

Now: Nothing replaces it.

Carousel slide "City Hall Parties at Your Expense" (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"Leaders Walking Away: Senior leaders retiring/transferring. Why walk away now? Do they know something we don't?"”
Verified

What the record shows: Senior departures are documented: the police and fire chiefs retired after careers of nearly four decades each, the Finance Commissioner retired in December 2025, and the City Manager left in April 2024 under a separation agreement worth up to $445,000. We found no source that gives a reason tied to wrongdoing or to the City's finances.

Now: The Leadership page lists the departures with sources and says that motives are speculation, not findings.

Carousel slides, The Wall card "City Hall Parties at Your Expense" (removed) and "Why are city officials partying so often" (kept as a question) · changed September 27, 2026
“"City Hall Parties at Your Expense! Lavish Events. Catered Dinners. Entertainment. All on YOUR Dime!" "Lavish catered city hall events while New Rochelle faces budget deficits, rising debt, and a dropping credit rating."”
Not found

What the record shows: We found no published record of what the City spends on events and celebrations, or on who paid for them. The budget documents we read do not itemize it.

Where we looked: The City's 2026 budget releases and department presentations, the audited 2024 and 2025 reports and news coverage through September 26, 2026.

Now: The lavish-events claims are gone. The Wall keeps one card that asks the question and marks it unresolved. A records request asks for event spending.

Carousel slides "Downtown Towers in Trouble" and "Downtown Project Failure"; The Wall cards "Deserves the Truth" and "Deserves Answers" (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"67% Occupancy?" "95% Needed to Break Even?" "One-Year Leases?" "Debt Keeping Up?" "Why does the city keep refinancing?"”
Not found

What the record shows: We found no published source for the occupancy, break-even or lease-length figures, and none was cited. The City's audited reports and the IDA's project data do not report private buildings' occupancy.

Where we looked: The IDA's 2018 minutes, the IDA project data reported to the State, the audited 2024 and 2025 reports and the 2021 Downtown Overlay Zone findings.

Now: Nothing replaces it.

Home page "Promised vs. Delivered" (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"Declining test scores, overcrowded classrooms, curriculum fights while $30K+ per pupil goes unaccounted."”
Verified

What the record shows: The State Education Department's public data show total expenditures of $32,305 per pupil in 2023-24, with 9,835 pupils. The amount is published, so it is not "unaccounted for." We did not assess the statements about test scores, classrooms or curriculum.

Now: Nothing replaces the sentence. The Budget and Finances page reports the per-pupil figure.

Home page "Promised vs. Delivered" (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"Rising crime, businesses fleeing."”
Verified

What the record shows: State data show 1,228 index crimes reported in 2024. That is 22% below 2012, 8.6% above 2019 and 24% above the 2021 low, so "rising" is true only from those low years. Employer businesses in the city's three ZIP codes went from 2,165 in 2018 to 2,120 in 2023, a 2.1% drop. Full-service restaurants fell from 86 to 71.

Now: The Fire, Alarms and Public Safety and Local Business pages report both series with their limits.

About page statistics · changed September 27, 2026
“"9K+ Registered Republicans"”
Verified

What the record shows: The Westchester County Board of Elections reported 8,114 active registered Republicans in New Rochelle on February 20, 2025, out of 50,152 active voters.

Now: "8,100+ Active Registered Republicans (Feb. 2025)."

The Wall, card "Where Did Westchester's ARPA Money Go?" · changed September 27, 2026
“"$187,926,698 came into Westchester in ARPA funds. Breakdown by category (housing, infrastructure, business support, healthcare, worker wages) and a call for receipts."”
Verified

What the record shows: Westchester County government received $187,926,698 in ARPA funds, in two payments in May 2021 and June 2022. The graphic's category figures come from two different County reports. Its $90 million labeled housing follows the County's 2024 progress report, and the County's 2025 report lists that $90 million as spent on programs for children with special needs. The five amounts add to $172.75 million, not the total. The figure does not include what cities, towns and villages received directly, including New Rochelle's $37 million.

Now: The card now states the verified total. The Finances page compares the County's two reports.

The Wall, card "Where Is New York's ARPA Money?", and carousel slide (removed) · changed September 27, 2026
“"Statewide ARPA breakdown: state general fund, local governments, NYC SLFRF, MTA, schools and housing. $50+ billion total." Figures included $12.75B, $10.7B, $5.88B, about $7B and $19.3B.”
Unresolved

What the record shows: This assessment did not check the statewide figures. It cannot say whether they are right.

Now: Nothing replaces it until the figures can be sourced.

Add your experience

Records show what the City reports. Residents and business owners know what it is like on the street. The Share page collects experiences and shows them only as unverified totals.

Share your experience