The Record

IDA Tax Breaks and PILOTs

How much tax the New Rochelle Industrial Development Agency has exempted, which taxes bear the cost, and what the public data do not answer.

DocumentedDisputed

Last verified October 2, 2026

Problem

Documented

From fiscal 2017 through 2024 the IDA reported $231.3 million in exemptions and $22.8 million in PILOT payments, for net exemptions of $208.5 million across 57 projects.

Documented

In fiscal 2024, 55% of the exemptions were school property tax and 16% were City property tax.

Evidence

$208.5 million in net exemptions, fiscal 2017–2024

Documented

What happened

From fiscal 2017 through 2024 the IDA reported $231.3 million in exemptions and $22.8 million in PILOT payments made, for net exemptions of $208.5 million across 57 projects. In fiscal 2024 alone it reported 45 projects, $36.5 million in exemptions, $6.1 million in PILOT payments and $30.4 million in net exemptions.

In fiscal 2024, exemptions were $20.0 million in school property tax (55%), $5.9 million in City property tax (16%), $5.9 million in sales tax (16%), $4.3 million in county property tax (12%) and $0.3 million in mortgage recording tax (1%).

When

Fiscal years 2017–2024.

Who is responsible

The IDA board, whose members the City Council appoints.

Evidence

What the City says

The Mayor said in May 2025 that PILOTs are “a predictable stream of revenue that grows alongside new development.” IDA data show PILOT payments rising every year, from $1.0 million in fiscal 2017 to $6.1 million in fiscal 2024.

Counter-context

Each year's figure counts every active project, so a long-running project appears in several years. In fiscal 2024, projects approved before 2016 accounted for 26% of exemptions; the current Mayor took office in January 2024.

Why it matters

Most of the exempted tax is school tax, which other taxpayers' bills help cover.

Open questions

  • Would these projects have been built without the incentives?

Compared with neighbors

Documented

What happened

In fiscal 2024 the New Rochelle IDA's net exemptions, $30.4 million, were about the same as Yonkers's, $30.5 million, although Yonkers has about 2.7 times as many residents. Per resident, New Rochelle's was $381, Yonkers's $144 and Mount Vernon's $74.

When

Fiscal 2024.

Who is responsible

The IDA board.

Evidence

What the City says

No public statement found.

Counter-context

The agencies differ in project mix and PILOT structure. The City describes New Rochelle as the state's fastest-growing city, so higher exemptions may reflect more construction. The data do not measure that.

Why it matters

It shows how heavily New Rochelle relies on tax breaks relative to its size.

The Stella's 30-year PILOT: sources disagree

DocumentedDisputed

What happened

On June 27, 2018 the IDA approved assistance for 14 Le Count Place, now the Stella: 379 rental apartments, 76 of them affordable at 50% to 60% of area median income, with a mortgage recording tax exemption of about $1,148,000, a sales tax exemption of $5,108,206 and a 30-year PILOT. State data show reported exemptions of $6.8 million across fiscal 2019 to 2024.

A 2018 Westfair report called it “a 30-year pilot costing $20.4 million” that “saves the developer $32.6 million in property taxes, a 62 percent break.” Our arithmetic from a resident-run tracker's figures suggests a 38% break. Neither is a primary record.

When

Approved June 27, 2018.

Who is responsible

The IDA board.

Evidence

What the City says

No public statement found.

Counter-context

The minutes say the 30-year term applies because the affordable portion uses low-income housing tax credits.

Why it matters

Thirty-year figures get quoted widely; the approved schedule would settle which is right.

Open questions

  • What is the approved PILOT schedule for the Stella?

IDA documents

City Policy Document · Revised March 29, 2023

How Developer Tax Breaks Work — the NRIDA Uniform Tax Exemption Policy

Documented

The New Rochelle Industrial Development Agency (NRIDA) is the city body that grants tax incentives to developers. State law requires it to publish a Uniform Tax Exemption Policy (UTEP) — the rulebook for who gets tax breaks, how much, and when they can be taken back. The current policy was adopted in 2016 and revised six times, most recently on March 29, 2023.

Three incentive tools

Exemptions from sales & use tax and mortgage recording tax, plus real estate tax abatements delivered through PILOT (payment-in-lieu-of-taxes) agreements.

10-year downtown PILOTs

Residential rental and commercial projects in the Downtown Overlay District typically receive 10-year PILOT agreements with a graduated abatement schedule (Schedule A) covering County, City and School taxes.

Social Equity Program

Every project must source 15% of total costs from local hire, union labor, or Women/Minority-Owned Business Enterprises — or pay a compliance penalty of $30 per net square foot, reduced by the percentage actually met.

Deviations & clawbacks

The NRIDA can grant bigger or longer breaks case-by-case after a cost-benefit analysis, and its clawback guidelines allow benefits to be suspended or recaptured if a project fails to deliver.

This summary paraphrases the policy document; the full text controls. Read the original for exact terms, schedules and definitions.

Read the full policy (PDF)
Agency Budget · 2026 Adopted Budget

The NRIDA's Own Budget — 2026 Adopted Budget

Documented

The NRIDA funds itself mainly through fees charged to the projects it assists — not directly from city taxes. Its 2026 budget shows how dependent that model is on new development deals closing.

2026 revenue: $870,400

Of that, $789,000 is one-time "transaction fees" from new development deals — nearly triple the 2025 projection of $217,232. The budget depends on a big jump in deals closing.

2026 spending: $397,600

The largest line is a $200,000 annual "Contract Services – City" payment to the City of New Rochelle, plus $150,000 for consultants and $25,000 for legal.

Reserves are shrinking

The agency's net position fell from $465,399 at the start of 2024 to a projected $244,058 at the start of 2026 — it spent more than it took in during 2024 and 2025.

Optimistic projections

The 2027–2029 outlook assumes transaction fees keep growing ($1.2M in 2027, $1.7M in 2028), rebuilding reserves to over $3.1M by 2029 — entirely dependent on the development pipeline.

Note: the document's column headers say "Proposed" while the file is titled "Adopted." Figures are quoted exactly as published in the budget document.

Read the full budget (PDF)
Certified State Filings · FY 2025 (certified March 31, 2026)

NRIDA Debt & Spending — 2025 Certified State Filings

Documented

Every year the NRIDA must file certified reports with the state's Public Authorities Reporting Information System (PARIS). The 2025 filings show what the agency owes and who it pays.

$28.1M in conduit debt

Outstanding conduit debt fell from $28,639,311 to $28,139,510 during 2025 — $499,801 retired, no new debt issued. Conduit debt is repaid by the assisted projects, not by the agency or taxpayers.

Four vendors, ~$337,600

All 2025 procurement spending went to four vendors: City of New Rochelle $200,000, National Development Council $112,363, Harris Beach Murtha $15,651 (legal), EFPR Group $9,570 (audit).

$200,000 to the City — non-competitive

The largest contract is the staffing and office services payment to the City of New Rochelle itself, awarded without competitive bidding — the same $200,000 line in the 2026 budget.

Legal firm retained since 2015

Harris Beach Murtha's legal services contract dates to December 2015 with no listed end date. The agency reports its procurement guidelines are reviewed annually, allow no exceptions, and that it issues no credit cards.

Options

OpinionProposal

Publish each cost-benefit analysis

Post the IDA consultant's cost-benefit analysis and PILOT schedule for every approved project.

Who would act: IDA board and City Council

Responds to: tb-totals, tb-stella

OpinionProposal

An annual clawback report

Report each year which projects met their commitments and whether any benefits were recaptured under the IDA's clawback policy.

Who would act: IDA board

Responds to: tb-totals

Questions

  • Would the projects have been built without the incentives?
  • Has the IDA ever recaptured benefits?

Records you can request

IDA cost-benefit analyses and PILOT schedules

To: Records Access Officer, New Rochelle Industrial Development Agency, 515 North Avenue, New Rochelle, NY 10801

Under the New York Freedom of Information Law, I request copies of the cost-benefit analysis, the approved PILOT schedule and any clawback or recapture determination for each project approved by the New Rochelle Industrial Development Agency from January 1, 2018 to the present.

If any part of this request is denied, please cite the specific exemption for each record withheld and tell me to whom I may appeal. I prefer electronic copies sent by email. If fees will exceed $25, please tell me before copying.

Thank you. [Your name] · [Email] · [Date]