The Record

Leadership, State of the City and Staffing

When the Mayor has given the State of the City address, the former City Manager's departure, and senior turnover, with what the record does and does not support.

DocumentedReported

Last verified October 2, 2026

Problem

Documented

Mayor Ramos-Herbert gave the State of the City address on April 11, 2024 and May 8, 2025. The 2026 address is scheduled for October 27, 2026 at JCC Mid-Westchester.

Documented

The City Charter requires an annual State of the City message but sets no date.

Documented

Former City Manager Kathleen Gill left in April 2024 under a separation agreement worth up to $445,000.

Evidence

State of the City: given in 2024 and 2025; 2026 set for October 27

Documented

What happened

City Charter Article III, Section 10 says the Mayor shall present an annual State of the City message. It sets no date, deadline, format or penalty.

Mayor Ramos-Herbert delivered the address on April 11, 2024 and May 8, 2025. The City posted the text of both. The 2026 address is scheduled for Tuesday, October 27, 2026 at 6:30 p.m. at JCC Mid-Westchester.

Former Mayor Noam Bramson delivered addresses on March 9, 2017, March 20, 2019 and March 9, 2023. We did not check 2018 or 2020 through 2022.

When

2017–2026.

Who is responsible

The Mayor.

Evidence

What the City says

The City announced the 2026 address and its RSVP form in September 2026.

Counter-context

The Charter sets no date, so a later address is not a violation. October 27 is later in the year than any of the five earlier addresses we could date since 2017.

Why it matters

The address is the Mayor's yearly public account of the City's condition and plans.

Open questions

  • Will the City post the 2026 text and video after October 27?

The former City Manager's departure and separation agreement

DocumentedReported

What happened

Former City Manager Kathleen Gill left in April 2024. The City Council ratified a separation agreement worth up to $445,000: about $279,000 for the rest of her contract plus five months, and up to about $166,000 for unused personal and sick time. The agreement also continues her health insurance at no premium unless she takes a job with another municipality that provides free retiree health insurance.

The Journal News reported a resignation on April 9 after the Council met in closed session, and quoted the Council's lone Republican calling it “a forced resignation.”

Wilfredo Melendez, Commissioner of Public Works since February 2023, became acting City Manager in April 2024 and was appointed effective December 1, 2024.

When

March – December 2024.

Who is responsible

The Mayor and City Council (appoint and remove the City Manager; ratified the agreement).

Evidence

What the City says

No public statement found.

Counter-context

The reasons for the departure have not been stated in the public record we found. The final payout depends on how much unused time she had accrued.

Why it matters

The City Manager runs day-to-day operations, including finance, and the payout is public money.

Open questions

  • What was the final amount paid under the agreement?

Senior turnover since 2024

DocumentedOpinion

What happened

Police Commissioner Robert Gazzola retired in June 2025 after nearly 40 years and was succeeded by Neil Reynolds. Fire Commissioner Andrew Sandor retired effective June 27, 2026 after nearly four decades and was succeeded by Joseph Sinatra. The 2025 financial report lists Alistair Featherstone as Finance Commissioner, where the 2024 report listed Edward Ritter.

When

2024–2026.

Who is responsible

The City Manager appoints department heads.

Evidence

What the City says

No public statement found.

Counter-context

We found no source tying the police, fire or finance retirements to wrongdoing. Claims that these leaders left because of something the public does not know are speculation, not findings.

Why it matters

Department heads run day-to-day operations; changes at the top affect continuity in police, fire and finance.

Options

OpinionProposal

A set window for the State of the City

A Council resolution asking for the address by the end of the first quarter, with a written report and a data appendix posted the same day.

Who would act: Mayor and City Council

Responds to: lead-sotc

Questions

  • What was the final amount paid to the former City Manager?

Records you can request

Former City Manager's separation agreement and payments

To: Records Access Officer, Office of the City Clerk, City of New Rochelle, 515 North Avenue, New Rochelle, NY 10801

Under the New York Freedom of Information Law, I request copies of:

1. The separation agreement between the City of New Rochelle and former City Manager Kathleen Gill ratified in April 2024.

2. Records showing the total amounts paid under that agreement, by category and date.

If any part of this request is denied, please cite the specific exemption for each record withheld and tell me to whom I may appeal. I prefer electronic copies sent by email. If fees will exceed $25, please tell me before copying.

Thank you. [Your name] · [Email] · [Date]