The Record

Budget, Audits and Financial Reporting

What the audited reports, the State Comptroller's filing records and the 2025 audit presentation show about New Rochelle's finances, and what is still unanswered.

DocumentedReportedPending

Last verified October 18, 2026

Problem

Documented

The General Fund's unassigned balance was $24.5 million at the end of 2023, $10.5 million at the end of 2024 (the lowest of the ten years in the audited report) and $23.1 million at the end of 2025.

Documented

At the June 9, 2026 Committee of the Whole, the City's outside auditor presented the 2025 audit. The minutes say he “commented that the City is moving in a good direction.”

Documented

The City's 2026 property tax rate is $269.695 per $1,000 of assessed value, up 2.46% from 2025. The City estimates about $103 more a year for the average home.

Evidence

State financial filings: “Not filed” four years running, then on time

Documented

What happened

The State Comptroller scores each city's fiscal stress from the annual financial report the city must file with it. Its published lists show New Rochelle as “Not filed” for fiscal years 2021, 2022, 2023 and 2024: the City had not filed by the date scores were calculated, so the State could not score it. The last year it filed in time was 2020 (score 16.3, “No Designation”).

For fiscal 2025 the City filed in time and scored 12.9, “No Designation,” which means no fiscal stress.

The City's audited 2024 financial report is dated November 5, 2025. Its 2025 report is dated June 30, 2026.

When

Fiscal years 2021–2024 (lists published 2022–2025). Fiscal 2025 scores published September 2026, with data as of August 31, 2026.

Who is responsible

Department of Finance prepares and files the report, under the City Manager (Kathleen Gill until April 2024; Wilfredo Melendez, acting from April 2024 and appointed effective December 1, 2024). The City Council oversees. Reports for fiscal 2021 and 2022 fell due under Mayor Noam Bramson; fiscal 2023 and 2024 under Mayor Yadira Ramos-Herbert, in office since January 2024.

Evidence

What the City says

No public statement found.

Counter-context

“Not filed” is not a stress rating. In both years New Rochelle was scored (2020 and 2025) it received “No Designation.” Moody's affirmed the City's Aa2 rating in November 2025.

Why it matters

The State's early-warning system had no reading on New Rochelle for four straight years, including 2024, when the General Fund's unassigned balance fell to its lowest point in ten years.

Open questions

  • On what date was each annual financial report actually filed?
  • Did the City request extensions, and why were the reports late?
  • What changed in the Finance Department for 2025?

The 2025 audit: “moving in a good direction”

Documented

What happened

At the June 9, 2026 Committee of the Whole, EFPR Group partner Thomas Smith presented the auditor's report for fiscal 2025. The minutes record: “He commented that the City is moving in a good direction.”

The audited 2025 report, dated June 30, 2026, carries an unmodified opinion on the financial statements and shows the General Fund's unassigned balance back up to $23.1 million.

When

Presented June 9, 2026. Report dated June 30, 2026.

Who is responsible

Finance Department and City Manager (the transactions and internal controls). City Council (appropriations and budget amendments). EFPR Group, CPAs (the outside auditor).

Evidence

What the City says

The auditor's “good direction” remark is in the official minutes.

Counter-context

The opinion on the financial statements was unmodified. Audit adjustments fell from 97 to 78. The report was filed on time. The audited report ties much of the reserve rebound to recognizing federal ARPA revenue, which is one-time money.

Why it matters

The Council controls spending through appropriations. Capital money is restricted to projects. A repeat material weakness means errors are more likely to go uncaught.

Open questions

  • What findings did the auditor report, and what is the City's corrective action plan?
  • Was the auditor's report on internal control filed with the City Clerk and sent to the State Comptroller, as General Municipal Law § 35 requires?

Reserves: a ten-year low in 2024, rebuilt in 2025 with one-time money

Documented

What happened

The audited 2024 report says the total General Fund balance fell $10.3 million, to $23.9 million, mainly because the City budgeted for a $5.0 million loss and settled a police union contract with retroactive pay dating to 2020. It describes about $8.0 million of that as a one-time expense.

The audited 2025 report says the General Fund balance rose $10.1 million, to $34.0 million, “driven by the revenue recognition related to the ARPA funding.”

When

Years ended December 31, 2024 and December 31, 2025.

Who is responsible

City Council (adopts the budget) and City Manager and Finance Department (carry it out).

Evidence

What the City says

The City says the 2026 budget does not use the unassigned fund balance for the first time in over a decade and presents this as a sign of strength.

Counter-context

Moody's affirmed the Aa2 rating in November 2025, and the City's release quotes the agency describing the 2024 decline as driven by one-time factors. The audited 2025 report puts net debt at 22.81% of the constitutional debt limit.

Why it matters

A balance rebuilt with one-time federal money does not show that ongoing revenue covers ongoing costs. ARPA money must be spent by December 31, 2026.

Open questions

  • How will the 2027 budget close any gap once ARPA money is gone?

Third-quarter 2026 budget amendment: $11.47 million moved, no reserves drawn

Documented

What happened

The Finance Department's third-quarter amendment to the 2026 budget adds $11,469,000 in spending authority across departments, including health insurance, workers' compensation, tax certiorari, contracted services and overtime lines. It is paid for by $6,900,000 in budgeted full-time salaries that are not expected to be spent and $4,569,000 in higher revenue estimates, including parking fines, fees and state aid. The two add up exactly to the new spending, so the amendment balances without drawing on reserves.

On October 13, 2026 the Committee of the Whole voted 7–0 to place the amendment on the consent agenda for the October 20 Regular Legislative Meeting, where the final vote is scheduled. The Finance Commissioner told the Council that revenue and expense accounts require adjustments based on current activity.

When

Committee vote October 13, 2026; final vote scheduled October 20, 2026.

Who is responsible

Finance Department (Commissioner Alistair Featherstone) and City Manager propose; City Council adopts.

Evidence

What the City says

The Finance Department's memo says the changes are meant to “more accurately reflect anticipated year-end activity, provide sufficient budgetary authority for projected expenditures, and align revenue estimates with updated expectations.”

Counter-context

Mid-year amendments are the normal way to keep spending within what the Council has approved. The 2025 audit reportedly found spending above appropriations in two funds; amending before year-end is how that is avoided.

Why it matters

The amendment shows where the 2026 budget missed: $6.9 million budgeted for full-time salaries is not expected to be spent, while other costs are running higher than planned.

Open questions

  • Which departments and positions account for the $6.9 million in unspent salaries?
  • How much of the $11.47 million is health insurance and tax certiorari refunds?

Options

OpinionProposal

A public filing calendar

A Council resolution setting deadlines for the annual financial report to the State Comptroller and for the audited report (by June 30), with a quarterly status line in the City Manager's report.

Who would act: City Council and Finance Department

Responds to: fin-filings

OpinionProposal

Post audit reports when they arrive

Post the auditor's report, the report on internal control and the management letter on the City website within ten days of receipt, the same window General Municipal Law § 35 sets for public notice. Post audit slides 72 hours before the meeting.

Who would act: City Council and City Clerk

Responds to: fin-audit-2025

OpinionProposal

A written policy for transfers between funds

Require Council approval for any advance between funds and publish the repayment schedule until it is repaid.

Who would act: City Council and Finance Department

Responds to: fin-audit-2025

OpinionProposal

A Council audit committee

A standing audit committee, or an internal auditor reporting to the Council, to follow up on findings between annual audits.

Who would act: City Council

Responds to: fin-audit-2025, fin-filings

Questions

  • Who authorized the roughly $19 million transfer from the capital projects fund, and has it been repaid?
  • When was each annual financial report filed with the State Comptroller from 2021 to 2024?
  • What is in the 2024 and 2025 reports on internal control and the management letters?

Records you can request

Auditor's reports on internal control and management letters, 2024 and 2025

To: Records Access Officer, Office of the City Clerk, City of New Rochelle, 515 North Avenue, New Rochelle, NY 10801

Under the New York Freedom of Information Law (Public Officers Law, Article 6), I request copies of:

1. The independent auditor's Report on Internal Control over Financial Reporting and on Compliance and Other Matters for the years ended December 31, 2024 and December 31, 2025, including the schedule of findings.

2. Any management letter issued by EFPR Group, CPAs, in connection with those audits.

3. The City's written responses and corrective action plans for those findings.

4. Records showing the date each of these reports was filed with the City Clerk, and any public notice given under General Municipal Law § 35.

If any part of this request is denied, please cite the specific exemption for each record withheld and tell me to whom I may appeal. I prefer electronic copies sent by email. If fees will exceed $25, please tell me before copying.

Thank you. [Your name] · [Email] · [Date]

Authorization and repayment of the 2025 transfer from the capital projects fund

To: Records Access Officer, Office of the City Clerk, City of New Rochelle, 515 North Avenue, New Rochelle, NY 10801

Under the New York Freedom of Information Law, I request copies of:

1. Any resolution, memo, approval or journal entry authorizing the 2025 transfer or advance from the capital projects fund to the General Fund described in the 2025 audit presentation of June 9, 2026.

2. Records showing the amount, the date of the transfer, and any repayment made since.

If any part of this request is denied, please cite the specific exemption for each record withheld and tell me to whom I may appeal. I prefer electronic copies sent by email. If fees will exceed $25, please tell me before copying.

Thank you. [Your name] · [Email] · [Date]

Annual financial report filings with the State Comptroller, 2021–2024

To: Records Access Officer, Office of the City Clerk, City of New Rochelle, 515 North Avenue, New Rochelle, NY 10801

Under the New York Freedom of Information Law, I request copies of:

1. Records showing the date the City filed its annual financial report (annual update document) with the Office of the State Comptroller for each of fiscal years 2021, 2022, 2023 and 2024.

2. Any requests for extension of those filings and the Comptroller's replies.

If any part of this request is denied, please cite the specific exemption for each record withheld and tell me to whom I may appeal. I prefer electronic copies sent by email. If fees will exceed $25, please tell me before copying.

Thank you. [Your name] · [Email] · [Date]