The Record

Accessibility of City Buildings

The State Comptroller's 2025 audit of accessibility at four City buildings, what the City agreed to do, and what has not been made public.

Official findingNot found

Last verified October 2, 2026

Problem

Official finding

The Comptroller found 171 of 895 accessibility components (19%) at four City buildings where officials could take additional steps: City Hall 97, the Senior Center 38, the Police/Court building 20 and Fire Headquarters 16.

Official finding

Across the 20 local governments in the same audit series, auditors flagged 1,491 of nearly 12,000 features, or 13%.

Not found

The audit asked the Council for a written corrective action plan within 90 days. We found no public copy of the plan and no public list of completed fixes.

State Audit · February 2025

Accessibility at City Facilities

Documented

The NYS Comptroller reviewed 895 ADA accessibility features at four City buildings (audit period Jan 2023 – Jun 2024) and found 171 (19%) where the City could do more — from missing parking signs to ramps that are too steep and doorways narrower than 32 inches.

97
City Hall

Van-parking signs, ramp slope, narrow doors, restrooms

38
Senior Center

Unmarked accessible parking, no Braille signs, twist handles

20
Police / Court

Elevator doors don't reopen, fixtures mounted too high

16
Fire HQ

Ramp missing a handrail, loose entrance mat

Worst categories: signs (25 of 32, 78%), curb ramps (40%), ramps (33%), elevators (21%), parking (20%). No issues were found with accessible routes, rooms or seating.

City's response: officials agreed with the findings and said they plan to start corrective action.

We have not found a public record of which fixes have been completed since the audit.

Read the full Comptroller report (PDF)

Evidence

State audit: 171 accessibility gaps at City buildings

Official finding

What happened

The Comptroller's audit S9-24-38, released February 21, 2025 and covering January 1, 2023 to June 30, 2024, found 171 of 895 components (19%) where City officials “could consider taking additional steps.”

At City Hall: signs for van-accessible parking, properly sloped ramps, interior doorways at least 32 inches wide and accessible restroom sinks. At the Senior Center: marked accessible parking, Braille signs and door hardware that does not require twisting. At the Police/Court building: elevator doors that reopen automatically and fixtures mounted too high. At Fire Headquarters: a ramp without railings on both sides and a loose entrance mat.

When

Audit period January 1, 2023 – June 30, 2024. Released February 21, 2025.

Who is responsible

The report states, “The Council has the responsibility to initiate corrective action.” Repairs are carried out through the City Manager and the Department of Public Works.

Evidence

What the City says

City officials agreed with the findings and said they plan to initiate corrective action (City's response in the report).

Counter-context

This was a statewide program covering 20 local governments, not an audit aimed at New Rochelle. The Comptroller described these as possible improvements, not legal violations. The audit period includes Mayor Bramson's last year in office.

Why it matters

Residents with disabilities, older residents and parents with strollers use these buildings for court, permits and senior programs.

Open questions

  • Which of the 171 items have been fixed?

The corrective action plan: due in 2025, not public

Not found

What happened

The audit asked for a written corrective action plan within 90 days, under General Municipal Law § 35, and encouraged the Council to make it available for public review in the City Clerk's office. That deadline fell in about May 2025.

We found no copy of the plan on the City's website and no public list of completed work.

When

Due about May 2025. Checked October 2, 2026.

Who is responsible

City Council (the plan) and City Clerk (public review copy).

Evidence

What the City says

No public statement found.

Counter-context

A plan may have been filed with the Comptroller without being posted. The Clerk's office can confirm.

Why it matters

Without the plan, residents cannot tell whether the City is fixing the problems it agreed to fix.

Open questions

  • Was the plan filed, and on what date?
  • Is there a budget line for the work?

Options

OpinionProposal

Post the plan and a fix tracker

Post the corrective action plan and a quarterly tracker of the 171 items, with dates and budget lines.

Who would act: City Council and Department of Public Works

Responds to: acc-audit, acc-cap

Questions

  • Which of the 171 items have been fixed, and which are scheduled?

Records you can request

Accessibility corrective action plan and completed work

To: Records Access Officer, Office of the City Clerk, City of New Rochelle, 515 North Avenue, New Rochelle, NY 10801

Under the New York Freedom of Information Law, I request copies of:

1. The corrective action plan prepared in response to the State Comptroller's audit S9-24-38 (Physical Accessibility to Programs and Services), and the record of its submission to the Comptroller.

2. Work orders, contracts or other records showing which of the audit's findings have been corrected, with dates.

3. Any capital budget line or appropriation for this work.

If any part of this request is denied, please cite the specific exemption for each record withheld and tell me to whom I may appeal. I prefer electronic copies sent by email. If fees will exceed $25, please tell me before copying.

Thank you. [Your name] · [Email] · [Date]